Medieval skeletons look older than their monasteries, thanks to fish (Image: Oxfordshire County Council / Anni Byard, CC BY 2.0. An early medieval skeleton excavated in England, not one of the Danish burials.)

Medieval skeletons look older than their monasteries, thanks to fish

Six skeletons from Danish monasteries were radiocarbon dated to before the buildings existed. Scientists say a diet heavy in freshwater fish threw off the dates.

Some skeletons buried in medieval Danish monasteries have a problem. According to radiocarbon dating, they died before the monasteries they’re buried in were built.

One skeleton from a Franciscan friary in the town of Svendborg was dated to between 1100 and 1155. The friary wasn’t built until 1236.

A team of scientists says the answer is pretty ordinary. These people ate a lot of fish.

Watch the Clownfish TV podcast on YouTube. Article continues below.

Why do the Danish monastery skeletons look too old?

Researchers from the University of Southern Denmark and the Center for Isotope Research at the University of Groningen re-examined bones from 27 people buried in medieval Danish monasteries.

Six of them, about 22 percent, came back with radiocarbon dates that were older than the monasteries where they were buried, sometimes by decades and sometimes by centuries.

The bodies came from three sites:

  • Svendborg: A skeleton from the Franciscan friary dated to 1100 to 1155, at least 80 years before the friary was built.

  • Viborg: A burial at the Monastery of Our Lady had a date range ending in 976 at the latest, more than 200 years before the monastery existed.

  • Om: Three burials at the Cistercian monastery in Om, in central Jutland, had the same problem.

The team published its findings in the journal npj Heritage Science.

Image: Nico-dk, CC BY 2.5. The ruins of the church at Om Abbey in Denmark.

“We can say with certainty that another five of the 27 skeletons we re-examined have also been incorrectly dated,” lead author Kaare Lund Rasmussen said in a University of Southern Denmark release. “The results make it abundantly clear that this is a major problem. And not just in Denmark, but probably across the rest of Europe too.”

How does eating fish mess up radiocarbon dating?

Radiocarbon dating works by measuring carbon-14, a radioactive form of carbon that’s created when cosmic rays hit the atmosphere.

Plants absorb it, animals eat the plants and people eat both. After death, no new carbon-14 comes in, and what’s left slowly decays. Measuring what’s left in a bone tells scientists roughly when that person died.

Water throws a wrench in that. Rivers, lakes and oceans can hold older carbon. ScienceAlert reported that rivers can contain around 15 percent less carbon-14 than the air.

Fish living in that water absorb the old carbon. Then the people eating those fish absorb it too, making their bones look older than they really are. It’s called the reservoir effect.

Image: Gilles San Martin, CC BY-SA 2.0. A northern pike, a common European freshwater fish.

“In extreme cases, a fish from the Rhine [River], for example, can appear up to 1,300 years older than a land-based organism that lived at exactly the same time,” Rasmussen said, according to ScienceAlert.

The tricky part is that freshwater doesn’t affect dates by a steady, predictable amount. “It can range from zero to 1,000 years,” he said.

Why did medieval Danes eat so much fish?

Religion, mostly.

“In Christian medieval Europe, meat was restricted during the lent period,” the researchers wrote. Freshwater fish got a pass, though, because it was seen as “cold” or “neutral” compared to meat from warm-blooded animals. In some Christian circles, freshwater fish was even considered a prestige food.

That fits the burials. Archaeology Magazine reported that the Svendborg skeleton got a high-status burial close to the church.

The team also found chemical proof of the fish-heavy diets. Every one of the 27 samples showed elevated levels of nitrogen-15, an isotope that’s high in aquatic food chains, according to the paper.

The same problem shows up in the Stone Age

The researchers say the issue isn’t limited to the Middle Ages.

ScienceAlert pointed to an example from a Stone Age site in the Balkans, where human remains were found pierced by arrows made from animal bone. The human bones came back as up to 500 years older than the arrows stuck in them.

Either an ancient prankster jammed fresh arrows into old bones, or the humans ate fish and the animals didn’t.

How can archaeologists fix radiocarbon dates?

The team’s advice is simple. Before trusting a radiocarbon date on human bones, especially medieval ones, measure the nitrogen-15 first.

“The word of warning is that it is necessary to assess whether excavated bones are affected by a freshwater reservoir effect, and if so, how large the reservoir effect could be,” the researchers wrote.

If the levels are high, models can help calibrate a more accurate age.

Saltwater fish cause a similar effect, but it’s easier to correct for. Freshwater is harder, because every river and lake is different.

Radiocarbon dating has been a go-to tool for almost 75 years, and it still works. It just needs to know what was on the menu.


Article compiled and written by Thom Pratt (editor-in-chief), Derek Gibbs (beat editor) and the Clownfish TV newsroom.


D/REZZED is part of Clownfish TV. For more news, views, and rants on gaming, tech, and pop culture, subscribe at clownfishtv.com. Watch the show on YouTube at @ClownfishTV where new episodes drop daily. Subscribe to the Clownfish TV podcast on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, iHeart, and wherever else you get your podcasts.


Hat Tips:

  • ScienceAlert (Nov. 14): Svendborg and Viborg dates, reservoir effect, Rasmussen quotes and Balkans example.

  • Phys.org and EurekAlert (Nov. 10-11): University of Southern Denmark release and Om burials.

  • Archaeology Magazine (Nov. 11): High-status Svendborg burial.

  • npj Heritage Science (Rasmussen, van der Plicht and Boldsen, 2026): Sample size and nitrogen-15 results.


AI Disclosure: All articles are assigned, edited and reviewed by an experienced human editor before posting. Like most modern newsrooms, WebReef Media uses a variety of AI tools to help with accuracy and efficiency. Ways AI may be used in article creation include research, grammar, fact-checking and ideation, as well as occasional AI generated or enhanced thumbnails or graphics. No articles are generated or posted without human oversight or involvement.

Scroll to Top