Pokemon fan game dev says Claude AI now refuses to help build it (Image: Xabi Vazquez, CC BY 2.0)

Pokemon fan game dev says Claude AI now refuses to help build it

A developer spending up to $2,000 a month making Pokemon Arena 2D with AI says Claude stopped helping. Anthropic says copying someone else’s game breaks its rules.

A Pokemon fan game built almost entirely with AI just ran into a wall, and the wall is the AI.

The developer behind Pokemon Arena 2D, who posts on X as Big Kid Nation, says Anthropic’s Claude has started refusing to work on the project. On Nov. 11, he posted that Anthropic “has cracked down and Claude models are starting to refuse work on Pokemon fan projects,” GamesRadar reported.

Full disclosure: D/REZZED uses AI tools, Claude among them, to help put articles together, as the note at the bottom of every post says.

Watch the Clownfish TV podcast on YouTube. Article continues below.

What is Pokemon Arena 2D?

It’s a free, real-time arena battler with pixel art, according to Kotaku. The developer has been aiming for a December release on mobile and PC.

In the project’s Discord, he said the game is “almost exclusively vibe coded now,” GamesRadar reported. Vibe coding means describing what you want in plain English and letting an AI write the actual code.

It hasn’t been cheap. Back on Oct. 9, he posted that the project meant “Up to $2,000 expenses a month” plus 10- to 14-hour days, Kotaku and Dexerto reported. Kotaku said that money went to AI tokens.

He also stressed that he never charged anyone. “All that money spent, never took a cent,” he wrote, pointing out that other fan projects take money through itch.io or Patreon.

What did Claude say when it refused?

Kotaku saw a screenshot of the refusal. In it, Claude told him, “The sprites show Pokemon characters, so a game built from them is a game starring those characters.”

It then suggested he build “original fighters in the same five roles” instead. Dexerto reported that Claude still said no after he explained the sprite files were on his own computer.

So the AI wasn’t against the game. It was against the Pokemon part.

Why is Claude refusing to make Pokemon games?

It traces back to a change Anthropic made for its newest model. Addy Osmani, who works at Anthropic, posted on Oct. 30 that “We added two sentences to Claude Code’s prompt on Opus 5.5,” Dexerto reported.

The gist, as GamesRadar quoted it, is “don’t build a recreation of a specific existing game.” Osmani also wrote, “Using Claude to infringe IP is against our usage policy.”

He said other projects should be fine: “Original games, genre games, and games built from your own designs and assets are meant to keep working.” Dexerto added that Anthropic later loosened things a bit, so people can mention an existing game to describe a genre or a mechanic, while straight copies still get turned down.

That puts a Pokemon fan game squarely on the wrong side of the line, since it’s built on characters somebody else owns.

Nobody has reported testing the same request on OpenAI’s or Google’s tools. GamesRadar said OpenAI “seemingly” has no matching rule for now.

What does the GTA 6 boss think about AI game clones?

Funny timing here. Take-Two CEO Strauss Zelnick, whose company publishes Grand Theft Auto, took a shot at AI companies in an interview with IGN, GamesRadar reported on Nov. 14.

“I think all companies should be protecting intellectual property, their own and everyone else’s,” he said. He added that it “seems ironic on the one hand to stomp on someone else’s IP and hope that yours is protected.”

He named Anthropic and OpenAI, but not any specific clone. Still, it sounds like at least one AI company is already doing some of what he asked.

Image: Christopher Michel, CC BY 2.0

Will Pokemon Arena 2D still come out?

The developer says yes. “Our game is still set for December,” he posted.

Whether Nintendo and The Pokemon Company let it stay up is a separate question. They have a long history of shutting down fan projects. Pokemon Uranium and the Metroid remake AM2R were both pulled in 2016 after notices from Nintendo’s lawyers.

Nintendo and The Pokemon Company also sued Palworld maker Pocketpair in Japan in 2024, though that’s a patent fight rather than a fan game case. They take this stuff seriously.

Fan games have always lived on borrowed time. This one may just have to finish the rest of its code the old-fashioned way.


Article compiled and written by Thom Pratt (editor-in-chief), Derek Gibbs (beat editor) and the Clownfish TV newsroom.


D/REZZED is part of Clownfish TV. For more news, views, and rants on gaming, tech, and pop culture, subscribe at clownfishtv.com. Watch the show on YouTube at @ClownfishTV where new episodes drop daily. Subscribe to the Clownfish TV podcast on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, iHeart, and wherever else you get your podcasts.


Hat Tips:

  • GamesRadar, Dustin Bailey (Nov. 11): The developer’s posts, the Discord quote and Osmani’s policy lines.

  • Kotaku, Alicia Haddick (Nov. 12): Game details, the $2,000 post and Claude’s refusal wording.

  • Dexerto, Zackerie Fairfax (Nov. 13): Osmani’s Oct. 30 post and the later rule change.

  • GamesRadar, Kaan Serin (Nov. 14): Strauss Zelnick’s IGN comments.


AI Disclosure: All articles are assigned, edited and reviewed by an experienced human editor before posting. Like most modern newsrooms, WebReef Media uses a variety of AI tools to help with accuracy and efficiency. Ways AI may be used in article creation include research, grammar, fact-checking and ideation, as well as occasional AI generated or enhanced thumbnails or graphics. No articles are generated or posted without human oversight or involvement.

Scroll to Top