Masahiro Sakurai says pitching the original Super Smash Bros. was tough because it broke fighting game rules, and a normal health-bar version would have been a forgettable novelty.
Super Smash Bros. is one of Nintendo’s biggest series today, but its creator says getting people to understand it in the first place was a real struggle.
Masahiro Sakurai looked back on the early days of Smash in comments to Japanese outlet Denfamicogamer, translated by Nintendo Everything and reported by GamesRadar on Nov. 16.
Watch the Clownfish TV podcast on YouTube. Article continues below.
Why was Super Smash Bros. hard to explain?
Back in the 1990s, fighting games had clear rules. Street Fighter 2 and Virtua Fighter set the standard. You had a health bar, you guarded and attacked, and when your health ran out, “you’re KOed and the match is over.”
Sakurai’s idea for Smash didn’t work that way. Instead of a health bar, fighters build up damage, and you win by knocking them off the stage. Positioning, platforms and ring-outs matter as much as combos.

That made it hard to pitch. Sakurai said Smash was criticized at the time by people who couldn’t get past how different it was from the fighting games they knew.
What if Smash had used normal fighting game rules?
Sakurai said he thought about a version with standard rules, with guarding, attacks and special moves, where a character loses when their energy runs out.
He doesn’t think that game would have made it. “I don’t think the original Smash Bros. would have been released like that,” he said. Even if it had, he believes it would have been seen as a “novelty” featuring Nintendo characters and wouldn’t have lasted the way the series has.
Instead, he trusted the unusual design. He said he was confident that ideas like damage accumulation and positioning would be fun, even if they were tough to explain.
Why is originality so hard in game design?
Sakurai said intentionally adding something new to a game is much harder than it sounds.
“But it’s actually very difficult to ‘intentionally add ingenuity,’” he said. Part of the problem is communication. When there are no earlier examples to point to, it’s hard to explain to a team what you’re aiming for.
That’s a familiar problem for anyone who has tried to pitch a new idea. It’s much easier to say “it’s like Street Fighter” than to describe something that doesn’t exist yet.
It’s also why so many games end up looking alike. Publishers and teams lean on proven formulas because they’re easier to sell, both inside a studio and to players. Smash is a rare example of a team betting on something unfamiliar and having it pay off for decades.
Sakurai has talked often about the value of a clear concept. Smash had one, even if it took players a while to see it: easy to pick up, chaotic with friends and deep enough for serious competition.
How big did Smash Bros. become?
Smash started as a prototype Sakurai built with the late Satoru Iwata at HAL Laboratory, a fighting game called Dragon King with no Nintendo characters. Adding Mario, Link, Pikachu and friends gave it the hook it needed.
The first Super Smash Bros. launched on the Nintendo 64 in 1999. It started as a smaller project but became a hit, and every Nintendo console since has gotten its own entry.
Super Smash Bros. Melee on GameCube in 2001 turned the series into a competitive staple that tournaments still play today. Brawl followed on Wii in 2008, then the 3DS and Wii U versions in 2014.
Super Smash Bros. Ultimate on Switch brought back every fighter in the series’ history and became one of the best-selling fighting games ever. Its competitive scene is also one of the biggest in the genre.
The damage-percentage system Sakurai describes is now so iconic that other games, like Warner Bros. Games’ MultiVersus, built their own platform fighters around it.
What is Sakurai doing now?
Sakurai has spent the last few years sharing design lessons through interviews and his popular YouTube series about making games. He also directed Kirby Air Riders, a follow-up to the cult GameCube racer Kirby Air Ride.
His comments on Smash are a reminder that some of gaming’s biggest successes started as ideas that were hard to explain. Smash didn’t win by being a better Street Fighter. It won by being something else entirely.
Article compiled and written by Thom Pratt (editor-in-chief), Derek Gibbs (beat editor) and the Clownfish TV newsroom.
D/REZZED is part of Clownfish TV. For more news, views, and rants on gaming, tech, and pop culture, subscribe at clownfishtv.com. Watch the show on YouTube at @ClownfishTV where new episodes drop daily. Subscribe to the Clownfish TV podcast on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, iHeart, and wherever else you get your podcasts.
Hat Tips:
-
GamesRadar (Nov. 16): Sakurai’s comments via Denfamicogamer and Nintendo Everything.
AI Disclosure: All articles are assigned, edited and reviewed by an experienced human editor before posting. Like most modern newsrooms, WebReef Media uses a variety of AI tools to help with accuracy and efficiency. Ways AI may be used in article creation include research, grammar, fact-checking and ideation, as well as occasional AI generated or enhanced thumbnails or graphics. No articles are generated or posted without human oversight or involvement.


