Lost Pokemon DS game found after 20 years, then sealed in a PSA slab (The PokePark Fishing Rally DS cartridge in its PSA case. Image: PSA / photo illustration)

Lost Pokemon DS game found after 20 years, then sealed in a PSA slab

A working cartridge for PokePark Fishing Rally DS, a 2005 Pokemon game that deleted itself, has surfaced. It went straight into a PSA case, and fans are begging the owner to dump the ROM.

A Pokemon game that was designed to vanish has finally turned up again. And then it went right into a plastic box.

A collector named Daniel Qudari showed IGN a working Nintendo DS cartridge that can send PokePark Fishing Rally DS to other DS systems over Download Play. The catch is that the cartridge was authenticated and sealed by PSA, the grading company best known for slabbing trading cards. The internet did not take that well.

Watch the Clownfish TV podcast on YouTube. Article continues below.

What is PokePark Fishing Rally DS?

PokePark Fishing Rally DS, also listed as PokePark Fishing Contest DS, was a tiny fishing game that was never sold in stores. In Japanese it’s PokePark Tsuri Taikai DS.

It was handed out over DS Download Play at PokePark, a temporary Pokemon theme park that opened in Nagoya, Japan, in March 2005. Bulbapedia lists its PokePark run as May 16 through Aug. 31, 2005. It was later offered at Pokemon Centers and Pokemon Festa.

Players cast a line and reeled in Water-type Pokemon like Magikarp and Feebas, scoring points based on each catch’s level, size and rarity.

The weird part is how it disappeared. Because it was a Download Play title, the game lived only in the DS’s memory. It deleted itself when the system was turned off, or after 12 hours, whichever came first. Nobody walked away with a copy, and no ROM has ever surfaced online.

How was the cartridge found?

Qudari hasn’t said where the cartridge came from. Kotaku called it the only confirmed fully playable copy.

Talking to IGN, Qudari described firing it up for the first time. “It felt surreal to turn on my DS and spend a quiet moment fishing,” he said, before reeling in a Gyarados.

Back in July, a German eBay seller listed a “Nintendo DS Development/Test Cartridge” that appeared to be tied to the game, with bidding starting at 7,999 euros. Text in the photos was translated as “Ranking Transmission,” so preservationists weren’t sure the game was on it. Generation Amiga reported that it sold for 9,505 euros. It’s not clear whether Qudari’s cartridge is the same one.

What did PSA do with it?

PSA’s public certificate, No. 616803-001, lists the item as a “Nintendo DS Event Distribution Cartridge” for PokePark: Fishing Rally DS from 2005. It doesn’t carry a number grade. The overall grade is “AU,” meaning authentic.

According to Dexerto, PSA researcher Claire Shelton played the game during a private meeting with the owner. Pirat_Nation reported that she spent about two hours with it before the cartridge was sealed into its case.

PSA’s pitch is that encapsulation protects a one-of-a-kind piece of history. Fans point out that a sealed slab can’t go in a DS.

Why are Pokemon fans mad?

Dexerto’s post about the slab racked up more than 560,000 views and 53,000 likes on X, and the replies were brutal.

Image: via @Dexerto, @sirshibaninja and @CableCardz on X

One of the first viral reactions came from X user KirbyCheatFurby, whose post was seen more than 169,000 times. He blasted the choice to slab the cartridge instead of dumping the game online so everyone could play it. “Collector, please crack that slab open and dump the ROM,” he wrote in a follow-up, adding that a new slab would be easy to buy afterward.

Others piled on. One reply with more than 5,000 likes called it gatekeeping and “a plastic prison.” Another user called the slab a plastic coffin.

A few people pushed back. Over on ResetEra, one poster pointed out that dumping the ROM isn’t risk-free. If a ROM appeared online right after one person revealed the only copy, they argued, Nintendo would know exactly where it came from.

Others noted that a fan-made remake built in Unity has been floating around Pokemon forums for years.

Will PokePark Fishing Rally ever be preserved?

Maybe. Kotaku reported that Qudari has expressed interest in helping preserve the game, and his cartridge can share the game with other DS systems. As of Saturday, no public ROM dump had been announced.

PSA cases can be cracked open, which is exactly what fans are begging for. Whether the owner wants to break that seal is another question.

For now, PokePark Fishing Rally DS is in the strangest state possible for a game that was built to delete itself. It exists, it works and it’s sitting in a plastic case where nobody can play it.


Article compiled and written by Thom Pratt (editor-in-chief), Derek Gibbs (beat editor) and the Clownfish TV newsroom.


D/REZZED is part of Clownfish TV. For more news, views, and rants on gaming, tech, and pop culture, subscribe at clownfishtv.com. Watch the show on YouTube at @ClownfishTV where new episodes drop daily. Subscribe to the Clownfish TV podcast on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, iHeart, and wherever else you get your podcasts.


Hat Tips:

  • IGN (Nov. 13, via Kotaku and Dexerto): Qudari’s working cartridge and his quotes.

  • Kotaku (Nov. 14): Cartridge source, preservation interest and game background.

  • Dexerto (Nov. 14): PSA researcher, fan reaction and PSA’s position.

  • Pirat_Nation on X (Nov. 14): PSA play session length.

  • PSA: Certificate No. 616803-001.

  • Bulbapedia, Lost Media Wiki and Notebookcheck: Distribution dates, gameplay and self-deleting design.

  • Notebookcheck, Nintendo Wire and Generation Amiga: July eBay listing and sale.

  • ResetEra and PokeCommunity: Fan discussion and fan remake.


AI Disclosure: All articles are assigned, edited and reviewed by an experienced human editor before posting. Like most modern newsrooms, WebReef Media uses a variety of AI tools to help with accuracy and efficiency. Ways AI may be used in article creation include research, grammar, fact-checking and ideation, as well as occasional AI generated or enhanced thumbnails or graphics. No articles are generated or posted without human oversight or involvement.

Scroll to Top